Apr 22
Digg
Stumbleupon
Technorati
Delicious

Parents Need to Keep their Role as Parents!

Betsy’s column filed Thursday, April 19th
@Scripps Howard News Service

Ah, for the unerring wisdom of a child …

“It’s just the two of us,” said one single-mom physician in Manhattan of her daughter, age 11. “That makes her more like a partner in some ways than a child.”

That’s the crux of the recent piece in The New York Times by Stephanie Rosenbloom, “Mom and Daddy’s Little Life Coach.”

That mom is hardly the only one. Rosenbloom chronicles the rise in children who advise _ more like instruct _ their parents, on everything from relationships to real estate deals.

Another mother, who has a top job at a literary firm, seeks advice from her 17-year-old because the woman just respects “how she looks at the world.” The daughter says she “never feels like she’s stuck in the parent-child stereotype …”

And that would be bad … because why? I would argue that a whole lot of 17-year-olds would benefit by being in a parent-child “stereotype”!

One single mom says of her 17-year-old son: “he advises me on everything.”

Too bad for her and the others that even MRI studies show that teens use the part of their brains governed by emotions to make decisions, whereas adults are more likely to use the parts of their brains related to planning, judgment and executive function. In fact, those “adult function” areas are not fully formed in the brain until a person reaches his 20s.

We really didn’t need an MRI study to tell us this, did we?

As Rosenbloom points out, parents have often looked to their kids for advice, from clothes _ “Does this look frumpy?” _ to where they want to go on vacation, to help with installing a new software program.

My own children like to advise me on the fact that I am a terrible cook, we need a dog and we ought to take a vacation to Hawaii _ for starters.

But Rosenbloom says today’s trend is different. That both the scope and nature of “… child-to-parent advice has reached new proportions for a variety of reasons. Many parents _ who have shed their status as old fogy untouchables and become pals with their progeny _ are treating their offspring as worldly equals,” she writes.

One cause seems to be material bombardment, which is now oriented in such a way that “it sells everyone on the notion that children are smarter now than in previous generations,” Susan Linn, a psychologist at Harvard Medical School, told the Times. There’s also the rise in single-parent families, with apparently many single parents (though not this one!) turning to their children to be their confidants. Maybe this is also about parents wanting to bond with their kids as pals because it’s not only “easier,” it makes Mom and Dad feel younger.

In any event, “we’re robbing children of childhood in some ways,” Linn said.

She’s right, but the trend is growing. Rosenbloom rightly ponders: What happens when these kids enter the work force? Will they be irritated when their managers don’t partner with them and seek their advice on all of the company’s decisions?

But I’m betting that one big reason for this shift is one not mentioned in the piece: the demise of religious tradition. The more we as a culture walk away from the latter and think we can do life on our own, the more we have to think our children come into the world inherently wise and virtuous _ because then that means we do, too.

Well, “As for me and my house,” to borrow from the Old Testament’s Joshua, I know that no matter how chaotic it may get around here, my kids are kids _ not my “partners” _ I’m the mom, and it’s for their sake that I have to care a whole lot more about whether they like me when they are 30 than when they are 13.

(Betsy Hart hosts the “It Takes a Parent” radio show on WYLL-AM 1160 in Chicago. She can be reached at www.BetsyHart.net.)

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!Share This Post
Author: Betsy

2 Comments

Rex Payne
April 23, 2007

I agree: Parents MUST not be buddies. But religion per se is not the solution. To the extent that high-functioning people tend to come from religious homes, it is because their parents were parents, not because their parents were religious. Religion does not cause moral fiber; it has tended to coexist with it. Morality is one thing, and religion another. Religion has no monopoly on morality. Religion is dogma [a set of absolute beliefs logically inseparable from mythology] masquerading as morality, natural law, basic values etc. and claiming to be the sole truth and the only path to ‘salvation’. It is the modern remnant of prescientific attempts to impose meaning and certainty on human existence and, in the case of Christianity, is obviously modeled on the paternalistic human family and its political outgrowth, monarchy. It is a fact that, generation after generation, religious people overwhelmingly adopt the religion of their parents, and that they do so at an age at which they are far too young to evaluate it or even to be aware that they are adopting it. Which religion one happens to adhere to is a matter of historical accident, not of self-evident truth. The greatest value of America is freedom of thought, and a basic assumption of the Constitution is that people can choose to be good, even without “God”. One relies on religion for goodness out of confusing the two or out of a vain hope that one’s own beliefs will someday be vindicated, and that insidious internal whisperer, Doubt, be forever silenced.

Betty C.
April 30, 2007

Dear Betsy,

I want to express my delight in reading your weekly commentaries in my local newspaper. I am thrilled to read such supportive Christian viewpoints, especially pertaining to raising children. I too, am a committed Christian mom striving to raise my 3 children in a Godly fashion. I repeatedly find myself uttering a resounding “AMEN!” to your statements. For example “The misperception that the sin is in the thing instead of the heart,” referring to a girls virginity, and also the one, “My goal for my children is heaven, not Harvard.” BRAVO, BETSY!!!
Keep sharing from the heart. Congrats on being asked to talk to the Willow Creek conference. What an honor. I look forward to getting your book. Wish I could hear your radio show. God bless you.

Sincerely,
Betty C.

P. S. I cut out most of your articles and share with my like-minded friends.

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment